Bankruptcy
Translation generated by AI. Access the original version
Serious tax penalties and exemption from unsatisfied liabilities
The Supreme Court (TS) has granted the exemption from debts to a person who was in a bankruptcy without assets , that is, without sufficient assets to meet their obligations. The decision allows access to this form of second chance despite the fact that the Treasury had opposed due to some serious tax penalties that remained unpaid in full.
The Treasury argued that the debtor had received final penalties for serious infractions amounting to over 5,000 euros. Both the commercial court and the Provincial Court accepted that argument and understood that there was a legal cause that prevented granting the exemption.
For the TS, the law requires good faith to access the debt cancellation and considers cases where certain serious tax penalties may prevent it. Among them are the penalties received during the 10 previous years prior to the application that exceed half of the exemptible amount by the Treasury, unless they have been fully paid before requesting the exemption.
However, the TS considers that the restrictions on this second chance must be justified and proportionate. In this case, it found no specific explanation to exclude individuals sanctioned for serious tax violations either in the preamble of the legal reform or in its preparatory works.
The court also distinguishes between serious and very serious violations, the latter involving fraudulent means , while in serious cases there is no need for fraud to exist. Therefore, understand that the two categories cannot be equated to deny the exemption.
The TS grants the requested cancellation, although it maintains the limitations applicable to certain public debts. These limitations affect privileged and ordinary credits; subordinated credits, a distinct category of credits, can be fully exempted.
If you find yourself in a similar situation, our professionals can advise you on the defense of your rights.RELATED CONTENT
-
Bankruptcy proceedings
Insufficiency of the generic judicial order for the cancellation of encumbrances
-
Bankruptcy
Exemption with payment plan after automatic liquidation in consecutive bankruptcy
-
Bankruptcy
Representative of the legal entity administrator in the guilty qualification of the bankruptcy
This website uses both its own and third-party cookies to analyze our services and navigation on our website in order to improve its contents (analytical purposes: measure visits and sources of web traffic). The legal basis is the consent of the user, except in the case of basic cookies, which are essential to navigate this website.